By Editorial Team 
Hania Amir’s single debut was supposed to mark ten years in showbiz. But instead it’s sparked a plagiarism debate with Shae Gill a coke studio breakout.
Hania Amir a famous Pakistani actress just released her new song “Pablo” on September 9, the song was billed a personal milestone: She completed ten years in entertainment industry, her first songwriting credit and a track that build to answer years of online scrutiny. But it was not supposed to be a plagiarism controversy. Within days listeners started comparing Hania’s new song with Shea Gill’s 2025 solo single breakout “insecurity” – And Pablo vs Insecurity comparison pulled Shae Gill herself as a harsh critic, and the Bollywood actress Rakhi Sawant.
What is Hania Aamir’s ‘Pablo’? A Quick recap
Pablo is a Punjabi hip-hop track that Hania Aamir wrote and composed by herself, she released it on her social media on September 9 to mark her ten years of experience in showbiz. The song starts with a soft piano line and then shifts towards an upbeat Punjabi rap in which Hania directly address critics of those people who have called her image “fake or guarded”. The song is produced, mixed and track mastered by Kamail Abbas while Hania Aamir directed the music video by herself with Mohammad Mohtashim on editing and cinematography.
And the most talked about moment is not just the Shae Gill, it is that the song closes with a surprise voice note from Indian reality TV personality Rakhi Sawant, in which she tells Hania Aamir not to let critics get to her. That was an unusual cameo that made headlines even before the copying accusations started.
What Is Shae Gill’s ‘Insecurity’? The Song at the Center of the Row
Shae Gill is the most known for her 2025 song “Pasoori” from Coke Studio with Ali Sethi that turned into a regional phenomenon. Her first solo song was “Insecurity” that was released on September 2025 as her proper introduction that she is a solo artist outside the Coke Studio. And to mark the song first anniversary she posted an acoustic version of “insecurity” this September a few days later Pablo dropped and that is the point where whole comparison started.
Pablo vs Insecurity: What’s Actually Fueling the Comparison
This was not a formal comparison between the two songs that are musically alike. Instead, the debate has largely driven by five factors:
1. Similar mood and delivery
Fans noticed similarities in the songs’ introspective tone, personal themes, and vocal delivery.
2. Timing
Gill’s acoustic reissue of Insecurity appeared during Pablo’s rollout, coinciding with the song’s first anniversary and fueling speculation online.
3. Similar musical space
Both tracks blend Punjabi influences with a singer-songwriter pop style, making comparisons more likely.
4. Debut vs. established artist
Aamir’s transition from acting to singing, compared with Gill’s established music career, added another layer to the discussion.
5. Social-media amplification
An Instagram comment questioning the originality of Pablo gained traction, turning an initial observation into a wider online controversy.
Shae Gill Breaks her silence
After getting tired of maintaining pressure Shae Gill addressed the speculation directly in her comments section. She pushed back on the idea that her acoustic post was a subtle dig at Aamir, saying she has never been the type to hate others and doesn’t intend to start. She clarified she’d released “Insecurity” the previous September and simply reposted an acoustic version to mark its first anniversary — nothing more.
She also added that the fans are free to enjoy whichever song they like. She closed the debate in a good natural way of closing without mentioning the name of Hania Aamir. She was also supported by fallow artist like Aima Baig and Abdul Hannan, reacting with emojis while Momina Munir, an actor influencer, asked Gill to release the full acoustic version.